Saturday, October 22, 2011

the goodman jesus and the scoundrel christ - philip pullman

Goodman Jesus

Pullman's Christ, what I liked: 
- I liked the tongue in cheek analysis of the life of Christ.
- The attempt to arrive at a realistic sequence of events is fairly successful
- The naive Jesus with his passionate and instinctive way of doing things is juxtaposed by a more analytical, organised, careful Christ. By making this distinction, the need for both types of skills is high lighted when one is starting out a new organisation. Jesus here is the one with the passion, the idea, the vision of a 'Kingdom of Heaven', while Christ is the one with the skill for organisation, for marketing the Jesus - vision with 'miracles', for creating a careful documentation of the birth of the organisation. You cannot have only vision or only organisational skills for creating and running a large successful enterprise........both are vital for starting and sustaining it.
In the course of documenting the events relating to Jesus - as they unfold, Christ is guided at crucial stages by the enigmatic 'stranger'. From this perspective, it is more a modern day tale of a venture capitalist who emerges as a shadowy 'stranger', a likely dry -fruits merchant.
- I liked the simple, lucid recital- i can recommend it to my fifteen-year old son to read.
- I liked the way all the well known parables of Christianity are skilfully woven into the Jesus and Christ story - the tale of the taxes to be paid using the coins with the emporor's head, the way people are stopped from stoning the woman accused of committing adultery.

- What made me think was the part where Jesus is shown to have no attachments, no regard for his mother and brothers, for eg, at the feast where Jesus is asked to do something about the wine which was almost over, and he shouts at his mother..... but eventually finds enough wine for all the guests.
Is it necessary to withdraw from the world to find God?
What about the parable of Vishnu, where Narada finds that he is not the greatest devotee, but it is a poor farmer with a large family? The farmer is immersed fully in the interminable task of living his life but Vishnu thinks of him as being closest to him, since he finds the time to remember Vishnu at all times of his busy day.
So is salvation attained through isolation or through living and participating in life?

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

snowdrops - a.d.miller

the book starts out dramatically with a dead body being discovered in the boot of a car parked on the street, when the thaw sets in moscow. nick, the hero, is constantly aware of his weakness - for young leggy girls, for living the rich life that moscow offers its expat citizens. He learns to look the other way when shady deals for non existent oil wells are being brokered at the office, when his beautiful young girl friends pretend to be sisters while they escort him around, when the girl friends 'help' their 'aunt' exchange her large spacious central moscow apartment for a half built apartment in the outskirts of moscow.
the visual imagery created in describing the moscow of the 1990's is beautiful. i could see in my mind's eye the snow as it falls on moscow and see its citizens slipping as they walked on the pavements, the short skirts that the girls wore and the cheap coats which looked opulent from a distance, the dacha that nick visited with his girlfriends, the train journey to the apartment that the 'aunt' is being conned to move into.
the fascination in reading this book lies in the curiosity that one demonstrates, in trying to find out the extent of nick's self deception.