the goodman jesus and the scoundrel christ - philip pullman

Goodman Jesus

Pullman's Christ, what I liked: 
- I liked the tongue in cheek analysis of the life of Christ.
- The attempt to arrive at a realistic sequence of events is fairly successful
- The naive Jesus with his passionate and instinctive way of doing things is juxtaposed by a more analytical, organised, careful Christ. By making this distinction, the need for both types of skills is high lighted when one is starting out a new organisation. Jesus here is the one with the passion, the idea, the vision of a 'Kingdom of Heaven', while Christ is the one with the skill for organisation, for marketing the Jesus - vision with 'miracles', for creating a careful documentation of the birth of the organisation. You cannot have only vision or only organisational skills for creating and running a large successful enterprise........both are vital for starting and sustaining it.
In the course of documenting the events relating to Jesus - as they unfold, Christ is guided at crucial stages by the enigmatic 'stranger'. From this perspective, it is more a modern day tale of a venture capitalist who emerges as a shadowy 'stranger', a likely dry -fruits merchant.
- I liked the simple, lucid recital- i can recommend it to my fifteen-year old son to read.
- I liked the way all the well known parables of Christianity are skilfully woven into the Jesus and Christ story - the tale of the taxes to be paid using the coins with the emporor's head, the way people are stopped from stoning the woman accused of committing adultery.

- What made me think was the part where Jesus is shown to have no attachments, no regard for his mother and brothers, for eg, at the feast where Jesus is asked to do something about the wine which was almost over, and he shouts at his mother..... but eventually finds enough wine for all the guests.
Is it necessary to withdraw from the world to find God?
What about the parable of Vishnu, where Narada finds that he is not the greatest devotee, but it is a poor farmer with a large family? The farmer is immersed fully in the interminable task of living his life but Vishnu thinks of him as being closest to him, since he finds the time to remember Vishnu at all times of his busy day.
So is salvation attained through isolation or through living and participating in life?

the gospel according to jesus christ - jose saramago

this is an unusual book on christ that i have recently read. it has a distinct narrative style, which i subsequently wanted to emulate. in the book, there are no chapter numbers or names. there is no punctuation except the comma and the full stop. the comma is used to indicate start and end of conversations, thoughts that the characters have and the description of the places.

it describes the life of christ as a very ordinary individual with just a passion for seeking God. But even in that pursuit it shows Christ to be full of doubts. The narrative of Christ's life with his parents, with his siblings, in a civilisation which is struggling under the yoke of the Romans is so vivid that it is necessary to continuously remind oneself- this is a book on THE Jesus Christ. There is nothing so sacred or so profane that it it becomes out-of-bounds for discussion in the book.

There is also a chapter devoted to a brilliant conversation between the Devil and God himself. This is the forty days when Christ was lost in the mists of the Sea of Galilee.This chapter where Christ speaks to God, with the Devil also invited, is a very thought provoking one. In the course of the discussion, the Devil proposes that for the word of God to spread to all corners of earth, God should receive the Devil into his heavenly kingdom, redeem the Devil's past offences by those he would not commit in the future, that God should also accept and preserve the Devil's obedience as it was in the happy days when the Devil was one of god's chosen angels -Lucifer. however God refuses the offer and tells the Devil that it is inconcevable that Good can exist without the Devil, the death of one would mean the death of the other, and that unless the Devil lived like the Devil, God cannot live like God.
God also predicts the manner in which Jesus Christ and his followers will die, as well as hundreds of thousands of people through the centuries who would be put to death because they believe in God - not because they will doubt Him. And the Devil says that one has to be God to enjoy so much bloodshed.

What i liked the most is the candid manner in which the foundations of christianity are discussed and questioned. there is no feeling of awe in the prescence of God which inhibits one's thought. It reminds me of the genius poet Kalidas, who prayed to Godess Kali till she appeared before him and offered him a boon. Kalidasa then said that he wanted both wit and wealth to make his way in the world, pleased by his boldness, Kali called him a 'vikatakavi' and granted him two boons instead of one.

a must-read for anyone with even a passing interest in Jesus Christ.